My first creation.

[argusz]

I'm Adrian, i go as "argusz" or "printicus". I want to present you with my ideea of toolheads for Voron 2.4 and Trident. I will very much appreciate an opinion.
The links are from thingiverse, but i can be found also on printables:

Miniburner XL Toolhead for Voron by printicus

This is Miniburner XL for Voron. Its a Toolhead designet to fit direct on the original Voron 2.4 or Trident carriage.It features two 5015 fans for part cooling and a 3010 fan for hotend cooling. This post is only for the hotend part of the build, the extruder part is in another post because it...

www.thingiverse.com

Miniburner Toolhead for Voron by printicus

This is Miniburner for Voron. Its a Toolhead designet to fit direct on the original Voron 2.4 or Trident carriage.It features two 4010 fans for part cooling and a 3010 fan for hotend cooling.This post is only for the hotend part of the build, the extruder part is in another post because it is...

www.thingiverse.com

Thank You.

 

[NoGuru]

Interesting design. Have you done any fluid dynamic testing to see how the air flows?

 

[argusz]

Interesting design. Have you done any fluid dynamic testing to see how the air flows?

No... you mean in software? No. I did all the design in Solid Edge CE. I don't think this free software has that. I will see how to do that...
I just started 3d drawing around a year ago, I did not try this, yet.

 

[NoGuru]

No... you mean in software? No. I did all the design in Solid Edge CE. I don't think this free software has that. I will see how to do that...
I just started 3d drawing around a year ago, I did not try this, yet.

I would at least do the bowl of water test on it to see how it looks when running part cooling. There are a few software that can do fluid simulations but I am unsure how difficult they are to learn.

 

[3dCase]

It is interesting indeed, and looking through the pictures of the XL, in picture Miniburner XL12.jpg it shows a breakout board which I would very much like to have identified?
The only comment I would like to make is that I do not believe people will dismantle their 5015 fans for fun to fit them in your designed holder, if I understood correctly. If this is indeed the case that you take them apart to fit the guts into your ducts, I think it would be better received if you changed the design slightly so you could fit the whole 5015 on a duct and just line it up with the mouthpiece. But that is my take on things, not necessarily so for all people I am sure.
I love the fact you use both a revo and a orbiter V2, I used them as a combo for a long time now and cannot praise them enough, well played.

 

[argusz]

It is interesting indeed, and looking through the pictures of the XL, in picture Miniburner XL12.jpg it shows a breakout board which I would very much like to have identified?
I think it would be better received if you changed the design slightly so you could fit the whole 5015 on a duct and just line it up with the mouthpiece.

I don' have the photos here, but in my pictures are three breakout boards: afterburner, stealthburner and LDO Nitehawk 36 usb board. I use Nitehawk 36 now.
For fitting the same form factor fan on both sides is dificult when you must consider some dimensions in x and y you must constrain the design... no mather what you still must chop some material of... so whats the diference? You would still destroy the casing in some extend.
My first iteration was like that, but between the partial fan casing and the needet printed parts to complete the fan there was little space for air flow.
Hei... you can test it with a cheap fan first... if its to your liking you just need to reprint one printed part.
I will post a video with the "bowl of wather" test. I did that, but never film it.

 

[Badnoob]

better than CFD or water dish tests is an actual print test, such as the Shuriken D85.

Chirpy has a good writeup on it.

voron/general/Duct_Testing at 5937508fad2eead9a7e3a68b8d60f6e527e56548 · chirpy2605/voron

Voron mods. Contribute to chirpy2605/voron development by creating an account on GitHub.

github.com

the important thing to do on htis test is to get your print time under 6 minutes, and try it with PLA and with ABS. PLA is a much harder test.

Let us know how the testing goes!

 

[argusz]

As requested this is the Shuriken85 Fan Duct Test. Under 6 min with Overture PLA. Two walls, no infil, no top layer, 10k accel.

 

[3dCase]

As requested this is the Shuriken85 Fan Duct Test. Under 6 min with Overture PLA. Two walls, no infil, no top layer, 10k accel.

That is looking good as far as I am concerned.

 

[NoGuru]

Yeah, I am impressed!